Choosing an estate agent is about more than finding someone who promises the highest price or offers the lowest commission. You need a property professional who understands your local market, gives you realistic advice, explains how your home will be marketed and keeps you informed throughout the sale.
A good working relationship matters too. Selling a home involves important decisions, negotiations and sometimes unexpected complications. You should feel comfortable asking questions and confident that you will receive straight answers.
Look for genuine local market knowledge
Ask how the agent arrived at the suggested price. A useful market assessment should consider recent comparable sales, competing properties, your home's condition and the features that may make it more or less appealing to likely buyers.
If two agents suggest very different prices, ask each to explain the evidence. The highest figure is not necessarily the most realistic, and an attractive asking price is not a guarantee of what a buyer will pay.
For more context, read our guide to how a home's market value is estimated (opens in a new tab).
Understand the proposed marketing plan
Ask the agent to explain what they intend to do, rather than simply listing every possible advertising platform. Useful questions include:
- How will the property be photographed and presented online?
- Will the listing include a walkthrough video, a floor plan or other material suited to the home?
- Which property portals and other channels will be used, and why?
- How will enquiries, appointments and viewing feedback be handled?
- Will the agent work with other qualified agents who may have suitable buyers?
The best approach depends on the property and the likely buyers. Our property marketing strategy explains how we approach these decisions.
Check credentials, experience and communication
Check that the property practitioner is appropriately registered with the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority and holds the required valid Fidelity Fund Certificate. Ask about relevant experience and request references if that would help you make your decision.
Also agree on how often you should expect feedback. You should know who will conduct viewings, who will handle offers and how you will be updated if buyer interest differs from expectations.
Compare the full service, not only the commission
Commission matters, but it is only one part of the decision. Discuss the rate, when commission becomes payable, any VAT implications, the proposed mandate and precisely what services are included.
Do not sign a mandate until you understand its duration, exclusivity, cancellation provisions and any possible commission obligations after it ends. You can read more in Seller Mandates Explained (opens in a new tab).
Questions worth asking before you appoint an agent
- Which recent sales do you consider most comparable to my property?
- What asking price do you recommend, and why?
- What will you do to market my particular home?
- Who will manage enquiries, viewings and negotiations?
- How often will I receive meaningful feedback?
- What does the mandate commit each of us to do?
Make a decision you feel comfortable with
An estate agent should help you understand your choices, not pressure you into a decision. Look for relevant knowledge, a practical marketing plan, transparent terms and communication you can trust.
Lydia and André Vorster have helped buyers and sellers in Cape Town's northern suburbs since 2005. If you're considering selling, we're happy to discuss your property and explain the approach we would recommend, without unrealistic promises.
YOUR NEXT STEP
A personal conversation can help.
Talk to Lydia & André about your property and your plans.
